This video discusses the global issue of reservoir sedimentation, using Lewis and Clark Lake as a prime example, where sediment accumulation threatens its functionality. All dams are temporary due to this inevitable process, which impacts both upstream reservoir capacity and downstream river ecosystems. The video explores current solutions for managing sediment, such as dredging, flushing, and sediment reduction upstream, highlighting the challenges, costs, and environmental considerations associated with each. It emphasizes the need for sustainable infrastructure and long-term planning in water management.
The Lewis and Clark Lake Example #
- Lewis and Clark Lake, on the Nebraska/South Dakota border, faces an "existential threat" from sediment.
- The reservoir provides hydropower, flood control, and recreational opportunities.
- Approximately 5 million tons of sediment enter the lake annually, where it settles.
- Since the 1950s, the reservoir has lost 30% of its storage capacity.
- A study predicts it will be half-full of sediment by 2045.
Impact of Dams on Sediment Movement #
- Downstream Impacts:
- Mainly environmental.
- Rivers naturally transport sediment, which carries nutrients, creates habitats, fertilizes floodplains, stabilizes banks, and forms coastal deltas/beaches.
- Dams cut off this natural sediment supply, altering downstream ecosystems.
- Upstream (Reservoir) Impacts:
- Reservoirs are more than just water collectors. Sediment accumulation reduces storage capacity.
Demonstrating Sedimentation with a Model #
- A model (acrylic flume) shows how fast-moving river water slows upon entering a reservoir, causing sediment (mica powder and colored sand) to fall out of suspension.
- Sediment forms a delta where the river meets the reservoir.
- The delta grows, progressively filling the reservoir.
Problems Caused by Reservoir Sedimentation #
- Reduced Storage Capacity: Undermines the primary purpose of reservoirs (flood control, power generation, water supply, irrigation, cooling).
- Recreational Impact: Shallower reservoirs limit navigation and foster algal blooms.
- Infrastructure Damage: Silt and sand clog gates, outlets, and turbines.
- Structural Stress: Sediment is heavier than water, adding unanticipated forces to dams.
- Inevitable Process: All natural rivers carry sediment; without intervention, every reservoir will eventually fill up.
- Factors Affecting Sedimentation Rate: Soil type (sandy soils erode faster), land use (vegetated areas hold soil better than agricultural land or wildfire-affected areas).
The Scale of the Problem #
- Dams are capital-intensive projects with significant monetary costs and downsides (environmental impacts, failure risks).
- Sedimentation is a long-term problem often pushed to future generations.
- The heyday of dam construction (1930s-1970s) means many dams are now reckoning with this issue.
- Society is increasingly dependent on these aging dams.
Current Approaches to Sediment Management #
-
Design Considerations ("Dead Pool"):
- Modern dams account for sediment during design.
- A "dead pool" volume is reserved for sediment accumulation.
- Low-level gates are placed above the dead pool to prevent clogging.
- This is a temporary accommodation, not a permanent solution.
-
Dredging:
- Method: Excavators, clamshell buckets, or suction dredgers remove sediment from the reservoir.
- Feasibility Issues:
- High cost: 1:1 ratio for volume of storage regained vs. sediment removed.
- Logistics: Moving millions of tons of wet sediment (e.g., 200,000 semi-trailers annually for Lewis and Clark).
- Spoil Handling: Sediment is wet, adding volume and making it difficult to handle; dewatering (e.g., using geotubes) is extra work.
- Contamination: Sediments can be contaminated, requiring special handling and disposal, and strict environmental regulations.
- Often not cost-effective.
-
Flushing (Passing Sediment Through the Dam):
- Goal: Allow sediment to continue downstream, benefiting river ecosystems.
- Methods:
- Low-level outlets: Consistently release turbid water, though most sediment deposits further upstream.
- Flushing the reservoir: Opening gates to increase water velocity to scour and resuspend sediment.
- Challenges:
- Ineffective in wide reservoirs: Often creates only a narrow channel, leaving most sediment.
- Operational constraints: Requires drawing down the reservoir, "wasting" water.
- Environmental impact: Sends a "massive plume" of sediment-laden water downstream, which can be considered a pollutant (e.g., regulated in the US).
- Difficulty matching natural sediment rates due to variability in reservoirs vs. rivers.
- Complicated regulatory environment.
-
Reducing Sediment Inflow (Upstream Management):
- Methods:
- Bedload interceptors: Devices in streams to remove sediment.
- Check dams: Trap sediment upstream, though this just creates more "reservoirs" that will fill with sediment.
- Soil conservation: Strategies to reduce erosion in the watershed.
- Soil Conservation Strategies: Maintaining vegetation (forests, grasslands), preventing wildfires, good agricultural practices, reforestation.
- Challenges:
- Scale: Watersheds for major reservoirs are enormous (e.g., Lewis and Clark's is 16,000 sq miles), making management complex and long-term.
- Limited effectiveness: Only so much can be done to completely prevent sediment.
- Methods:
Conclusion #
- Reservoir sedimentation is a global problem affecting virtually all on-channel reservoirs.
- Despite challenges, engineering lessons from past oversights provide new tools for sustainable infrastructure.
- Large-scale water management involves complex technical, political, and social issues.
Nebula Promotion #
- Promotes Nebula, a streaming service for independent creators.
- Offers early access to videos, exclusive content (Practical Construction series), and an ad-free experience.
- Highlights a specific documentary, "The Colorado Problem: A River in the Red," available on Nebula.
- Offers a 40% discount on annual plans and lifetime memberships.
last updated: