Summary: Apple's decline in market value from 2021-2023 dominance to third place in 2025 is attributed to prioritizing profit over product innovation under Tim Cook's leadership. This shift contrasts sharply with Steve Jobs's hardware-centric approach that propelled Apple's earlier success. Overpriced iPhones, a lack of significant innovation, and anti-competitive practices, coupled with a delayed and fabricated AI strategy, have led to stagnant sales, declining market share, and multiple lawsuits, raising concerns about Apple's future direction.
Apple's Decline in Market Value
- Apple was the most valuable company globally from 2021 to 2023.
- Fell to second place in 2024, with Microsoft taking the lead for half the year.
- Dropped to third place in 2025, behind Nvidia and Microsoft.
- Experienced a 28% value shrinkage in 4 months, totaling a $1.1 trillion loss.
- Reasons cited include overpriced iPhones leading to stagnant sales, lack of innovation, and anti-competitive business practices resulting in lawsuits.
Shift from Product Focus to Profit Focus (Steve Jobs vs. Tim Cook)
- The transition began in 2011 when Tim Cook took over as CEO from Steve Jobs.
- Steve Jobs prioritized great products, believing stock price would follow, exemplified by saving Apple from bankruptcy by focusing on hardware (iMac, iPod, iPhone).
- Jobs rejected advice to move to software, despite lower hardware profit margins, and refused dividends or stock buybacks to strengthen Apple.
- Tim Cook, known for financial and logistical skills, implemented Apple's first dividend and stock buyback program in 2012, significantly boosting stock price.
- Warren Buffett, historically against tech investments, invested heavily in Apple under Cook, implying confidence in Cook's financial engineering approach.
Impact on Product Development and Innovation
- Cook's leadership led to a shift from "industrial engineering" to "financial engineering."
- Jonathan Ive, former Chief Design Officer, experienced challenges to his ideas, especially those increasing costs, under Cook.
- Apple's product releases became less innovative; iPhones from 2014-2017 looked similar, and older products like iPods saw price drops with significant improvements.
- Post-2017, iPhone prices soared (e.g., iPhone X at $1,000, 15 Pro Max at $1,200), driving up average selling prices despite declining innovation.
- Internal emails suggest Apple aimed to innovate "just enough" to maintain sales without impacting profit margins.
- Stagnation in hardware design is noted for iPhones, iPad Pro, Apple Watch, and other accessories post-2019.
- Vision Pro is Apple's only significant new product since 2019, reportedly underperforming sales expectations.
Product Launch and Marketing Issues
- Apple's premature announcement of AirPower in 2017, intended to deter customers from buying competitors' wireless chargers, led to its eventual cancellation in 2019.
- Historically, Apple products were released soon after announcement (e.g., original iMac, iPod, iPad).
- Under Cook, announcing products "many months in advance" became routine (e.g., Apple Watch, Apple TV+, Mac Pro, Vision Pro), a strategy often used to reassure shareholders and build excitement.
Falling Behind in AI and Consequences
- Apple, despite pioneering voice assistants with Siri in 2011, fumbled its lead in AI.
- Competitors like Google, Microsoft, and Amazon surpassed Siri's accuracy by 2017.
- Siri's reliance on outdated rule-based systems contributed to its stagnation.
- The release of ChatGPT in 2022 highlighted Apple's AI deficit, as it used advanced generative AI models.
- Apple's finance team reportedly hampered AI development by limiting the purchase of necessary GPU chips.
- Despite having over $150 billion in cash, Apple spent significantly more on stock buybacks ($77 billion) than on AI infrastructure ($10 billion for chips) in 2023.
- Apple Intelligence, revealed in 2024 to appease shareholders, was criticized for being largely fabricated and not ready for release.
- Key AI features, including an improved Siri, faced repeated delays, leading to a false advertising lawsuit.
- Reports indicate a truly conversational Siri might not be available until 2027.
Current State and Future Outlook
- Apple now functions more like a finance company, leading in stock buybacks but lagging in R&D spending compared to competitors.
- Shareholders generally favor Cook's leadership due to increased market cap, but this comes at the expense of product innovation.
- The company's focus on profit and complacency in innovation could lead to its downfall.
last updated: