Summary: This video compares and contrasts dips and bench press exercises, discussing their pros, cons, and effectiveness for building upper body strength and muscle. It addresses common misconceptions about calisthenics and weight training, highlighting the benefits of each exercise and ultimately recommending a hybrid approach for optimal results and injury prevention.
Stereotypes and Misconceptions
- Barbell lifts are often seen as the primary, serious exercises.
- Bodyweight movements like dips are often considered secondary or just "finishers."
- There is a misconception that bodyweight exercises are inferior to barbells.
Dips: Pros and Cons
- Cons:
- Equipment availability and bar width issues in commercial gyms can be a problem.
- Lack of customization in equipment can lead people to skip the exercise.
- Can be too challenging for beginners to perform with full bodyweight.
- Require more shoulder mobility than the average person possesses.
- Requires kinesthetic awareness to achieve the proper range of motion.
- Pros:
- Being leaner makes dips easier, creating a positive feedback loop for maintaining a healthy lifestyle.
- Allows for greater range of motion, which is effective for hypertrophy.
- It is a closed kinetic chain exercise that builds bodyweight strength and stability.
- Promotes healthy shoulder function due to scapular movement.
- Builds resilient, flexible, and strong shoulders when range of motion is gradually increased.
- Adding weight allows for progressive overload and significant strength gains.
- Strong performance in dips correlates with maximizing relative strength (pound-for-pound).
- Performing weighted dips commands respect and is visually impressive.
Bench Press: Pros and Cons
- Pros:
- Easier for beginners to master compared to dips, allowing for gradual progression with lighter weights.
- Bulking tends to increase bench press linearly up to a certain point due to increased body mass and improved leverages (reduced range of motion).
- Accessible in most gyms with readily available barbells and dumbbells.
- Generally causes less shoulder stress compared to weighted dips due to lower shoulder flexibility demands.
- Allows for relatable comparison with others ("How much can you bench?").
- Targets the entirety of the pecs (horizontal pressing).
- Incline bench press can specifically target the upper chest fibers.
- Cons:
- Can be susceptible to ego lifting and cheating (bouncing bar, arching back, lifting hips).
- Cheating can manifest in subtle ways (cutting range of motion, explosive tempo).
- Can enable complacency when bulking, masking potential weight gain.
- Has poor transfer to calisthenics exercises like the planche or handstand push-up.
- The external stability of the bench reduces the need for stabilizing muscles compared to dips.
Muscle Activation Comparison
- Bench press (horizontal press) targets the entire pecs.
- Dips (vertical press with forward lean) emphasize the lower pecs and sternal fibers, similar to a decline bench press.
- Dips involve significant shoulder extension, creating a large stretch through the chest, especially the sternal fibers.
Why Do Both?
- Variety: Prevents burnout and boredom, making training more enjoyable.
- Well-Rounded Development: Builds both muscle mass and the ability to move your body freely through space.
- Specific Goals: For those not competing in single-discipline strength events (powerlifting or street lifting), a balanced approach is beneficial.
- Injury Prevention and Movement Diversity:
- Reduces repetitive stress on joints and tendons.
- Spreading stress across different movements is less risky than prioritizing one exercise.
- Specializing in only one exercise can lead to overuse injuries.
- Diversifying pressing movements leads to healthier joints, tendons, and overall body.
- Continued Progress:
- Progress eventually stalls with any single exercise.
- Alternating between dips and bench press as the primary and accessory lift provides a novel stimulus and prevents accommodation.
Recommended Variations
- Bench Press:
- Barbell bench press (if comfortable).
- Dumbbell bench press:
- Offers greater range of motion.
- Demands more stability, strengthening the rotator cuff.
- Provides a unilateral focus, ensuring balanced development.
- Dips:
- Parallel bar dips (if equipment is suitable and feels good).
- Calisthenics rings:
- Excellent substitute for bad parallel bar equipment.
- Offers greater freedom of movement and can be more comfortable for joints.
- Can help develop flexible, strong, and robust shoulders.
Conclusion
- Both dips and bench press are valuable for building upper body strength and muscle.
- Excluding either exercise means missing out on potential gains.
- Combining both exercises leads to superior results ("the sum is greater than the parts").
- Combining movements addresses specific weaknesses that might arise from only doing one.
last updated: