Doctor Who Is Finally Dead - Let It Rest In Peace

Decline of Doctor Who #

• The speaker believes the show started to decline around David Tennant's era, pointing to the Christmas specials where the Doctor became a "joke" and a "buffoon" rather than primarily a serious character.
• The introduction of the "Timeless Child" storyline is cited as a major turning point that fundamentally altered the Doctor's origin, making him the origin of the Time Lords themselves, which the speaker views as a narcissistic and damaging retcon.
• The speaker criticizes the handling of regeneration, particularly the 13th Doctor's regeneration into the 14th Doctor, claiming it lacked the emotional weight and explanation of previous regenerations and felt "lazy."
• The casting of Jodie Whittaker as the 13th Doctor is mentioned as a point where the show became "too overtly political" for the speaker, suggesting a focus on diversity over established character.
• Emphasis is placed on the show's departure from its original premise and the dilution of the companion's role into simply "the Doctor's friend."

The "Woke" Agenda and Forced Diversity #

• The speaker frequently uses terms like "woke," "virtue signaling," and "forced diversity" to describe what they perceive as the BBC's agenda in the show.
• References are made to the promotion of "LGBTQXYZ" storylines and the perception that the BBC is pushing a specific social narrative rather than focusing solely on entertainment.
• The speaker suggests that the BBC's financial struggles and reliance on license fees mean they prioritize pleasing a small, vocal minority rather than the general audience.
• The casting of Ncuti Gatwa is framed as another example of "forced diversity" and a continuation of the "woke" agenda.
• The speaker asserts that the show became about "ticking boxes" rather than good storytelling.

Russell T. Davies' Return and Disney+ Involvement #

• The speaker expresses disappointment that Russell T. Davies, despite his previous success, is seen as returning to continue the "woke" direction of the show, rather than restoring it to its former glory.
• The involvement of Disney+ is viewed negatively, with the speaker speculating that Disney imposed demands for diversity and inclusion as a condition for their investment.
• The increased budget due to Disney+ is mentioned, but the speaker believes it is being misspent on catering to a "woke" audience rather than improving the show's core quality.

Historical Revisionism and Moralizing #

• The speaker criticizes instances where the show is perceived to be rewriting or misrepresenting historical figures and events, such as the portrayal of figures from the Suffragette movement.
• The show is accused of "lecturing" the audience and becoming overly preachy, imposing modern political views onto historical settings.
• The speaker expresses a desire for entertainment that doesn't feel like a "sermon."

Financial State and Future of Doctor Who #

• The show's declining viewership and financial struggles are highlighted, with the speaker suggesting that the show is no longer profitable for the BBC.
• The reliance on Disney+ funding is seen as a sign of the show's inability to sustain itself.
• The speaker proposes that the show should be "put to bed" and allowed to rest, arguing that its best days are long gone and that continuing it in its current form will only tarnish its legacy further.
• The potential for spin-offs is dismissed, with the speaker reiterating that the franchise should be allowed to die.

Summary #

The speaker argues that Doctor Who has fundamentally declined, attributing it to a shift towards a "woke" agenda, forced diversity, and political messaging from around the David Tennant era, culminating in the "Timeless Child" retcon and the casting of the 13th Doctor. They criticize the show's perceived focus on "ticking boxes" over compelling storytelling, its "lecturing" tone, and its financial struggles. The return of Russell T. Davies and the involvement of Disney+ are seen as continuing rather than reversing this negative trend. The core argument is that the show has become unrecognizable and unwatchable, and should therefore be permanently ended to preserve its legacy.