The general advice to "just get a Steam Deck" is not always the best solution, as the Steam Deck, while versatile, isn't perfect for every use case. While it excels in many areas like indie games and offers great value for AAA titles, other dedicated handhelds or PCs might be more suitable depending on specific needs such as portability, battery life for retro games, or raw power for the latest AAA releases.
Reasons for the "Just Get a Steam Deck" Advice #
- Swiss Army Knife of Handhelds:
- Runs indie games perfectly.
- Handles most big, modern PC games.
- Emulates retro games exceptionally well.
- Capable of desktop PC functions (though not recommended for productivity).
- Integrated Ecosystem:
- Seamless access to Steam library and cloud saves.
- Proton enables Windows games to run efficiently.
- Minimal setup; "log in, play, happy."
- Price Point:
- Offers a strong balance of power and affordability compared to other high-end handheld PCs.
When the Steam Deck is NOT the Best Choice #
- Retro Games:
- Pros of Steam Deck: Powerful, can emulate almost anything including Xbox/PS3, excellent bang for buck performance. Can be transformed into a retro handheld with tools like "Retro Deck."
- Cons of Steam Deck:
- Performance isn't always the primary concern for retro gaming; mid-range retro handhelds can handle most GameCube/PS2/Switch.
- Larger and heavier, not pocket-friendly.
- Can be less comfortable for extended retro gaming sessions due to size.
- Many dedicated retro handhelds have better controls for specific retro games.
- Dedicated retro handhelds offer superior battery efficiency and instant wake-up times (days of standby vs. hours).
- Indie Games / Older PC Games (Low-Spec):
- Pros of Steam Deck: "Backlog Obliterator," excellent battery efficiency at low TDP (most efficient PC handheld), runs actual PC games seamlessly. Can be docked for a home console experience.
- Cons of Steam Deck: May be overkill if simply playing indie games on an existing TV or computer, as a much cheaper mini PC (~$150) can often handle these games.
- AAA PC Games:
- Pros of Steam Deck: Surprisingly capable for AAA games given its price, developers optimize games for Steam Deck due to its popularity.
- Cons of Steam Deck:
- Can struggle with demanding AAA titles, leading to lower battery life, increased heat, and fan noise.
- Cannot compete with more expensive, higher-spec handheld PCs in terms of raw performance for the latest games.
- Not the best choice for those who prioritize playing the latest AAA games at their highest possible settings.
- Desktop Mode:
- Pros of Steam Deck: Provides full Windows-like PC functionality (running desktop apps, mods, productivity software), "Linux nerd heaven" for customization and tinkering.
- Cons of Steam Deck:
- Small screen (7-inch), lack of built-in keyboard makes it inconvenient for serious PC tasks.
- Not as convenient or powerful as a dedicated desktop PC or laptop for daily computing needs.
- A comparable mini PC might be a better fit if desktop functionality is a primary requirement.
Conclusion #
- The Steam Deck is a fantastic, versatile device, especially for indie games and offering great value for AAA titles.
- However, it's not the ideal solution for everyone or every use case.
- Dedicated retro handhelds offer better portability, battery life, and often better controls for older games.
- More expensive handheld PCs provide superior performance for cutting-edge AAA titles.
- Mini-PCs can be a more cost-effective solution for simply playing indie games on a larger screen or for basic desktop tasks.
- The decision to get a Steam Deck should be based on individual needs and priorities, rather than generalized advice.
last updated: