The primary drivers of muscle growth are hard training and sufficient caloric intake, with protein playing a supportive, rather than primary, role. Over-consuming protein beyond a certain threshold offers minimal additional benefit for muscle growth and can be costly, displace other important macronutrients, and lead to discomfort. Optimal protein intake varies based on individual goals, body composition, and activity levels, but is often lower than commonly believed.
The Misconception of High Protein Intake #
- Historical Context: Bodybuilders in the "golden era" consumed over 300 grams of protein daily, a practice that influenced the "1 gram per pound of body weight" rule.
- Food Industry Exploitation: The food industry capitalized on the protein obsession, leading to overpriced "high protein" snacks and products, often just adding cheap protein.
- Scientific Challenge: New research questions the necessity and effectiveness of very high protein intake for muscle growth.
Research Findings on Protein and Muscle Growth #
- Large-Scale Analysis: A group of top protein researchers analyzed 62 long-term growth studies, plotting protein intake against muscle growth.
- Unexpected Results: Studies showed that doubling protein intake from 0.45 grams/pound to 0.9 grams/pound (e.g., 82g to 164g for a 180-pound person) resulted in nearly identical muscle growth.
- Diminishing Returns: Even higher protein intakes (e.g., 270 grams/day) sometimes correlated with less muscle gain.
- Flattened Trend: Across studies with moderate to high protein intakes, the trend for muscle growth was "basically flat," indicating minimal additional benefit from pushing protein higher.
- Expert Opinion (Dr. Eric Trexler): Eating more protein than the body needs is like having more bricks than a house blueprint calls for; it doesn't build a bigger house, just leads to leftover waste.
Real-World Example: Alex Leonitis (Pro-Natural Bodybuilder) #
- Dietary Shift: Alex reduced his protein intake from 200 grams/day to as low as 90 grams/day, exclusively from plant-based sources, for 2.5 years.
- No Negative Impact: He reported no adverse effects on recovery, progressive overload, or muscle gains, maintaining elite natural lifting performance.
- Savings: Lower protein intake resulted in cost savings and reduced stress about hitting high protein targets.
What Actually Builds More Muscle Than Protein #
- Hard Training: Studies show that without training, even high protein intake (140g/day) yields no muscle growth.
- Sufficient Calories:
- Patients with kidney issues on very low protein diets (<50g/day) still gained significant muscle and strength when they started lifting weights.
- A study comparing extra carbohydrate intake (2000 calories) to extra protein intake (2000 calories with 82g protein) showed similar gains in weight and muscle for both groups, implying calorie surplus was the key driver.
- Severe calorie deficits (500-700 calories/day) can lead to muscle loss even with high protein intake.
- Conclusion: The most important drivers of growth are hard training and eating enough calories to fuel training and recovery. Protein plays a supporting role.
Downsides of Excess Protein Intake #
- Satiety and Caloric Intake: Protein is highly satiating and requires more energy to digest, making it harder to consume enough calories for growth if you struggle to gain weight.
- Gastrointestinal Discomfort: High protein diets can cause discomfort and flatulence.
- Cost: Consuming unnecessary extra protein is expensive (e.g., $5/day for 100g of chicken protein vs. <$1 for equivalent calories from carbs).
- Displacement of Macronutrients: Excess protein can displace carbs and fats, leading to:
- Low Fat: Can negatively impact hormone levels.
- Low Carbs: Drains glycogen stores, reducing workout performance.
When Protein Does Offer Major Benefits #
- Transition from Very Low to Moderate Intake: Increasing protein from very low levels (below 0.55g/pound of body weight) to moderate levels can lead to a "meaningful bump in gains." Below 90g/day, recovery can be noticeably slower for some individuals.
- Dieting/Calorie Restriction (especially for lean individuals):
- Protein's satiating effect helps manage hunger during calorie deficits.
- For individuals below 15% body fat and dieting, protein needs are higher to preserve muscle.
- Adherence and Enjoyment: Some people simply prefer or enjoy eating protein, and it contributes to adherence to a dietary plan. Protein powder offers a quick, tasty, and versatile way to get protein.
Recommended Protein Intake #
- Majority of Lifters: 0.55 to 0.63 grams per pound of body weight (e.g., 88-100 grams for a 160-pound person). This range is close to maximizing gains, considering protein from all food sources.
- Extra Assurance/Maximizing Gains: 0.64 to 0.72 grams per pound.
- Dieting (below 15% body fat) or Absolute Maximization: 0.73 to 1 gram per pound of body weight.
- Personal Example: The speaker previously consumed over 1g/lb, now consumes closer to 0.73g/lb with no difference in gains and improved digestion and training performance.
- Convenience: Hitting protein targets can be as simple as adding one protein shake per day.
Call to Action #
- Use a calculator or an app (like Built with Science Plus) to determine individual protein needs.
- Prioritize hard training and sufficient caloric intake.
- Check out other videos for training advice.
last updated: